My Goodison No.35: Sapphire And Diamond

My Goodison No.35: Sapphire And Diamond

3 April 25

By Deborah May

Share

We have so many special memories of home games at Goodison Park. Our happiest memory, though, was an autumn evening game on 3 October 1989 – and it is a date imprinted on our hearts forever.  

It was a Littlewoods Cup second round, second leg match against Leyton Orient. We would normally have been situated in the Lower Gwladys Street terrace – where we have our season tickets – but Pete had bought tickets in the Upper Bullens Road that evening to a be closer to the scoreboard... He was about to hit me with the surprise of my life!

Prior to the match, the scoreboard lit up with the words 'Deborah, will you marry me? - Love Peter', I had no idea that the message was meant for me. At the time, Pete had gone for something to eat. When he arrived back to his seat I told him to look at the scoreboard, which was still showing the message. Little did I know it was for me until Pete got down on one knee and presented me with a sapphire and diamond engagement ring (blue and white stones, of course!) and asked me to marry him. I said yes, immediately!

The date had been significant to us both as we had met on 3 October 1986. Pete had been going to watch Everton  since the late 1970s. A week after we met, he took me on a date to Goodison Park for my first time. I had loved football all my life and I was blown away by the atmosphere of the crowd. It was a special season, too. as we went on to win the league title that year. I had fallen for Pete first and then I fell the Blues – and we haven't looked back since.

Pete, a shy man, had not realised how much attention we would then receive following his proposal. For the next three days we were inundated with press reporters asking us for interviews. We hit the front page of the Liverpool Echo and the Daily Post. The Daily Mirror also reported on it.  We were invited by Everton to take a tour around Goodison Park. The soap series, Brookside, also contacted us to say they were using Pete's idea in one of their storylines where one of the characters proposed to another at Goodison Park.

We were married nearly two years later, on 25 May 1991 - we chose a date that wouldn't clash with any Everton games so we didn't have to miss any! We were given a further surprise by the Club... A wedding card signed by Howard Kendall and the 1990/91 squad. It was our favourite gift of the day and has been kept safely since.

We now have two daughters who also join us at some of the games and we remain Season Ticket Holders to this day. We will be so very sad to say goodbye to Goodison Park - it's our happy place, where we have so many special memories, particularly the evening of 3 October 1989.

We look forward to next season at our new home at Everton Stadium but we will be leaving Goodison Park with the heaviest of hearts on the final game this season. All we have to say is, thank you, Goodison, for all the wonderful memories.

By Deborah May and Peter May, Evertonians

A series of first-hand accounts describing moments that made us fall in love with Goodison Park, My Goodison - supported by the Club's Main Partner, Stake - is a new weekly offering here on evertonfc.com, bringing you the most-treasured memories of fans, players, and staff both past and present, for our final season at the Grand Old Lady.

Got an entry? We'd love to hear it. Email us via digital.content@evertonfc.com

RELATED NEWS

© Copyright 1878 - 2026 Everton Football Club