The views below are submitted by registered users of evertonfc.com and do not necessarily reflect the views of Everton Football Club. View the Blueroom acceptable usage policy.

Drenthe replaces Pienaar NOT Arteta
  • bluedayz
    Posts: 120
    I would just like to draw everyones attention to the fact that we did sell Pienaar in January and he was not replaced.
    Pienaar is a left winger and coincidently so is Drenthe.
    Therefore Arteta is so far NOT replaced.
    Thanks.. now I've got that off my chest :)
  • Knoxy2001e
    Posts: 1,430
    prefer peanut to arteta. thought he did good for us.
  • MavisCruet
    Posts: 1,794
    Arteta doesn't play anywhere we haven't got players for, and has played worse than most in those positions of late.  Drenthe replaces Pienaar and then some, he's twice as fast and has twice the hair!
  • bluedayz
    Posts: 120
    Of course we have players to play where Arteta played but if what your saying is the case then why even have a squad? We might as well just choose 11 players and fingers crossed we'll do well.
    We have a lot of games ahead of us and the players who can play in Artetas position will get tired or injured as Arteta did last season but who will replace them when they do?
  • milky71
    Posts: 9,136
    Osman,rodwell,Barklay,Drenthe,Fellaini,Cahill,Heitinga,Baxter,Wallace.

    Arteta palyed 1 good game last season and that was on the left of midfield.

    Drenthe will hopefully surpass that
  • MavisCruet
    Posts: 1,794
    My point was we didn't have anyone to play on the left.  Now we do.  So from having lots of players for the centre and nominally the right, we have one less and now have gone from 0 to 1 on the left.  A more balanced squad.
  • MavisCruet
    Posts: 1,794
    milky71 said:

    Osman,rodwell,Barklay,Drenthe,Fellaini,Cahill,Heitinga,Baxter,Wallace.

    Arteta palyed 1 good game last season and that was on the left of midfield.

    Drenthe will hopefully surpass that



    So glad you didn't include Neville in that list Milky :)
  • milky71
    Posts: 9,136
    Shudder at the thought mate
  • Irony
    Posts: 199
    Coleman was in the midfield as well.... I like this signing, hopefully Real Madrid are looking to offload him but I doubt it. Drenthe is insanely quick and gladly takes his opportunities when given space. I haven't seen much of him but what I have seen he will certainly fill in when needed because of his versatility.
  • bluedayz
    Posts: 120
    Yes I have to agree with you crusty... left mid was a bigger priority to us than the centre. I actually don't think we'll miss him all that much, he played like a crab of late which annoyed the hell out of me but the reason for this thread is due to the fact that so many people are saying the board done well, we replaced Arteta with Drenthe forgetting the fact that Pienaar left wit hno replacement.
    I beleive we have enough quality in the youngsters to step into Artetas shoes but it doesn't aid the fact that our small squad is now smaller thanks to the incompetant board yet again.
  • blue4eva77
    Posts: 276
    I reckon Ross Barkley replaces Arteta long term..... So yeah he is replaced.

    Coincidently, Barkley seems to give the team that little extra something that Arteta used to do.

    Yes, its raw talent right now but once the edges have been smoothed out, we will see something better than Arteta could give.  Lets not forget Coleman is to come back from injury....
  • milky71
    Posts: 9,136
    Irony said:

    Coleman was in the midfield as well.... I like this signing, hopefully Real Madrid are looking to offload him but I doubt it. Drenthe is insanely quick and gladly takes his opportunities when given space. I haven't seen much of him but what I have seen he will certainly fill in when needed because of his versatility.



    Drenthe is in his last year of his contract
  • 11blue
    Posts: 4,765
    I don't care who he replaces as long as Arteta is off the wage bill.
  • bluedayz
    Posts: 120
    blue4eva77 said:

    I reckon Ross Barkley replaces Arteta long term..... So yeah he is replaced.

    Coincidently, Barkley seems to give the team that little extra something that Arteta used to do.

    Yes, its raw talent right now but once the edges have been smoothed out, we will see something better than Arteta could give.  Lets not forget Coleman is to come back from injury....



    So Barkley is like a new signing I guess??? Sorry I couldn't resist the pun!

    Are you a board member?
  • weverett
    Posts: 137
    Barkley has already played better this season than Arteta has in any match in the last year.  Arteta suffers from the same thing that pienaar did and cahill does - too often he is "almost great".


  • bluedayz
    Posts: 120
    weverett said:

    Barkley has already played better this season than Arteta has in any match in the last year.  Arteta suffers from the same thing that pienaar did and cahill does - too often he is "almost great".





    Agreed but getting rid of him at 10m with no replacement isn't the answer.
  • weverett
    Posts: 137
    bluedayz said:

    weverett said:

    Barkley has already played better this season than Arteta has in any match in the last year.  Arteta suffers from the same thing that pienaar did and cahill does - too often he is "almost great".





    Agreed but getting rid of him at 10m with no replacement isn't the answer.


    I think the answer already exists.  Barkley/Cahill/Felliani/Rodwell/Etc... show pretty strong depth in center mid.  We needed a permanent left wing is we arent going to play Billy in that position (which is a pity, imo).  

    The problem we have had for the last year is the lack of scoring pressure.  I prefer we add the striker in place of Arteta and put stronger ball control in the middle.  Barkley and Rodwell/Felliani would be my preference.  
  • ScouseBlues
    Posts: 235
    If Drenthe is as good as he could as he could be, then he will link up well with Baines, Barkley will replace Arteta, we have a strong midfeild without Arteta, he's been missing for over a year anyway, im glad he's off the wage, he's 30 in 6 months and has an injury once a season, im not really that arsed he's gone
  • Markie D
    Posts: 58
    bluedayz said:

    I would just like to draw everyones attention to the fact that we did sell Pienaar in January and he was not replaced.
    Pienaar is a left winger and coincidently so is Drenthe.
    Therefore Arteta is so far NOT replaced.
    Thanks.. now I've got that off my chest :)



    We have replacements for Arteta, but they never got a game however bad his form was.

    Bily, Osman.

    Plus, we now have Barkley to play in the middle, how is that a bad thing?
  • ScouseBlues
    Posts: 235
    Markie D said:

    bluedayz said:

    I would just like to draw everyones attention to the fact that we did sell Pienaar in January and he was not replaced.
    Pienaar is a left winger and coincidently so is Drenthe.
    Therefore Arteta is so far NOT replaced.
    Thanks.. now I've got that off my chest :)



    We have replacements for Arteta, but they never got a game however bad his form was.

    Bily, Osman.

    Plus, we now have Barkley to play in the middle, how is that a bad thing?

    Exactley, he would come back from injury and walk straight back in to the first team even though he was playin crap, just like Baines taking the freekicks an corners an nearly everytime makes does something with it, then Arteta comes in an he's first on the ball hitting the first man again

    The Arteta of 2007 has gone, we luckily had his best years, and I thank him for all the good days we got from him but like he said it was the right time for him, it was also the right time for us



  • East Belfast Toffee
    Posts: 21
    Is it true that Drenthe held the Everton shirt in the air as if he couldn't care less about being at the club?
Add a Comment

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Forum

Poll

No poll attached to this discussion.

In this Discussion