The views below are submitted by registered users of evertonfc.com and do not necessarily reflect the views of Everton Football Club. View the Blueroom acceptable usage policy.

Harry's gone mad? Moyes is worse, no Duffy?
  • xreyuk123
    Posts: 785
    Why has he been dropped, was our best player against Blackburn.
  • scottinfrance139347
    Posts: 2,312
    i think he should play but who has replaced him?
  • xreyuk123
    Posts: 785
    **** hibbert.
  • scottinfrance139347
    Posts: 2,312
    hibbert at center back?
  • xreyuk123
    Posts: 785
    Yup. Well, him or Neville.
  • Jxg
    Posts: 1,537
    Duffy has talent - This I will not argue against.

    What he lacks, is experience. Hibbert has played hundreds of games for the first team against much stronger sides; Duffy has not. He lacks the knowledge of bigger games and now is not time to give him the experience. We need this point (or 3). Hibbert, while he may not be as good, is much more reliable.

    Duffy might be also be ill. We don't know.
  • OldGoldenVision
    Posts: 19,472
    Kick in the teeth for duffy. disappointed for the lad...
  • cjohno
    Posts: 5,112
    Jxg said:

    Duffy has talent - This I will not argue against.

    What he lacks, is experience. Hibbert has played hundreds of games for the first team against much stronger sides; Duffy has not. He lacks the knowledge of bigger games and now is not time to give him the experience. We need this point (or 3). Hibbert, while he may not be as good, is much more reliable.

    Duffy might be also be ill. We don't know.


    -----------------



    hes played hundreds of games but is still shittttttt and even experienced he still does the same stupid tackles and lack any positional sense what soever hes learnt nothing over the years, odds for him to be sent off for 2 stupid tackles
  • Jxg
    Posts: 1,537
    cjohno said:

    Jxg said:

    Duffy has talent - This I will not argue against.

    What he lacks, is experience. Hibbert has played hundreds of games for the first team against much stronger sides; Duffy has not. He lacks the knowledge of bigger games and now is not time to give him the experience. We need this point (or 3). Hibbert, while he may not be as good, is much more reliable.

    Duffy might be also be ill. We don't know.


    -----------------



    hes played hundreds of games but is still shittttttt and even experienced he still does the same stupid tackles and lack any positional sense what soever hes learnt nothing over the years, odds for him to be sent off for 2 stupid tackles

    -----------------



    I can't really say anything else other than "you're wrong".

    He's played hundreds of games and, while he may not be as talented as Duffy, he knows what to do in games like these. We can't take a chance with Duffy at this time, as much as I want to.
  • zagan
    Posts: 4,703
    well at least we know Nev aint in midfield.....
  • scottinfrance139347
    Posts: 2,312

    Kick in the teeth for duffy. disappointed for the lad...


    -----------------



    same i think he`s been rock solid bu will get moved to the back when distan and jags are fit
  • xreyuk123
    Posts: 785
    Well considering they are playing Dzeko, we needed Duffy's height. Heitinga is not tall, and Hibbert is a short ****.
  • OldGoldenVision
    Posts: 19,472
    Three across the back with hibbo man marking aguero?
  • IhateRS
    Posts: 1,091
    I'm normally a positive person but I would drop Duffy. I don't see what he will learn conceeding 5 or 6 goals.
    At least with Hibbert we have someone who has experience to deal with players much quicker than him.. Play Duffy in games we have a reasonable chance but this one would be a massive morale dent if the likely defeat happens.
  • cjohno
    Posts: 5,112
    Jxg said:

    cjohno said:

    Jxg said:

    Duffy has talent - This I will not argue against.

    What he lacks, is experience. Hibbert has played hundreds of games for the first team against much stronger sides; Duffy has not. He lacks the knowledge of bigger games and now is not time to give him the experience. We need this point (or 3). Hibbert, while he may not be as good, is much more reliable.

    Duffy might be also be ill. We don't know.


    -----------------



    hes played hundreds of games but is still shittttttt and even experienced he still does the same stupid tackles and lack any positional sense what soever hes learnt nothing over the years, odds for him to be sent off for 2 stupid tackles

    -----------------



    I can't really say anything else other than "you're wrong".

    He's played hundreds of games and, while he may not be as talented as Duffy, he knows what to do in games like these. We can't take a chance with Duffy at this time, as much as I want to.

    -----------------

    we shall see wont we, dzeko must be looking forward to this 2 centre halfs with no height, were going to struggle big time at set pieces but it dont matter hibberts experience will give him another 6 inches at corners and his positional sense will see him through, looooooooooooooool

  • Jxg
    Posts: 1,537
    IhateRS said:

    I'm normally a positive person but I would drop Duffy. I don't see what he will learn conceeding 5 or 6 goals.
    At least with Hibbert we have someone who has experience to deal with players much quicker than him.. Play Duffy in games we have a reasonable chance but this one would be a massive morale dent if the likely defeat happens.


    -----------------



    This.
  • beardblue boy
    Posts: 381


    hes played hundreds of games but is still shittttttt and even experienced he still does the same stupid tackles and lack any positional sense what soever hes learnt nothing over the years, odds for him to be sent off for 2 stupid tackles

    -----------------



    Couldnt agree more with this.....hes always out of position and aalways dives in....RUBBISH!.
  • cjohno
    Posts: 5,112
    well i really hope im proved wrong and hibbert has a blinder aND city have an off night
  • escla
    Posts: 2,450
    xreyuk123 said:

    Why has he been dropped, was our best player against Blackburn.


    -----------------


    Was he fu'ck !Did you notice a guy called Donaven?
    Id

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Poll

No poll attached to this discussion.

In this Discussion