The views below are submitted by registered users of evertonfc.com and do not necessarily reflect the views of Everton Football Club. View the Blueroom acceptable usage policy.

Who is Everton's best player?
  • Sydjenko
    Posts: 135
    My order would be:

    1: Baines
    2:Jagielka
    3:Fellaini
    4:Arteta
    5:Cahill
  • milky71
    Posts: 9,113

    lukep08 said:

    fellaini without a doubt, saha and arteta aswell when both fit and on form.



    People have such short memories.

    Felli don't get me started, Saha didn't score for 11 months and Arteta was shocking all of last season.

    Osman outshone all our midfielders Beckford scored the same as Saha witha lot less game time and Bily scored more than Arteta.

    Agree that Baines is the best player we have
  • 11blue
    Posts: 4,765
    milky71 said:


    lukep08 said:

    fellaini without a doubt, saha and arteta aswell when both fit and on form.



    People have such short memories.

    Felli don't get me started, Saha didn't score for 11 months and Arteta was shocking all of last season.

    Osman outshone all our midfielders Beckford scored the same as Saha witha lot less game time and Bily scored more than Arteta.

    Agree that Baines is the best player we have


    Fellaini is class and you know it, but for some reason you won't admit it.
  • lukep08
    Posts: 309
    milky71 said:


    lukep08 said:

    fellaini without a doubt, saha and arteta aswell when both fit and on form.



    People have such short memories.

    Felli don't get me started, Saha didn't score for 11 months and Arteta was shocking all of last season.

    Osman outshone all our midfielders Beckford scored the same as Saha witha lot less game time and Bily scored more than Arteta.

    Agree that Baines is the best player we have



    Your right thats why i said WHEN FIT AND ON FORM, for me when saha is playing his best he is by far our best player he has bags and bags on class. just cant stay fit, arteta had 1 bad season and about 5 class seasons, he is still a class player, dont know what you have got against fellaini 95% of fans agree saying he's class
  • lisa2blonde
    Posts: 43
    lol - Hibbert
  • Baumans916
    Posts: 116
    Arteta if he ever regains his old form.....
  • AndyCOYB
    Posts: 96
    LEIGHTON BAINES BEST
  • 1ceablue
    Posts: 3,253
    Baines.....
  • milky71
    Posts: 9,113
    lukep08 said:

    milky71 said:


    lukep08 said:

    fellaini without a doubt, saha and arteta aswell when both fit and on form.



    People have such short memories.

    Felli don't get me started, Saha didn't score for 11 months and Arteta was shocking all of last season.

    Osman outshone all our midfielders Beckford scored the same as Saha witha lot less game time and Bily scored more than Arteta.

    Agree that Baines is the best player we have



    Your right thats why i said WHEN FIT AND ON FORM, for me when saha is playing his best he is by far our best player he has bags and bags on class. just cant stay fit, arteta had 1 bad season and about 5 class seasons, he is still a class player, dont know what you have got against fellaini 95% of fans agree saying he's class


    This i can't agree with.

    I believe 95% of the fans have fallen for Moyes little Felli speech and believe he is great when in reality he has had 10-15 good games in 3 seasons.

    1 pirouette against Man city doesn't make you world class

    And i also believe we will lose money on him when he leaves
  • beardblue boy
    Posts: 406
    Baines is by far our best and most influential player,Jags is one of our most important to keep players,and i have to agree with milky i must be watching a different game to you lot when Fellaini is playing,hes clumsy and got the touch of a baby elephant and always seems to be only one tackle away from being sent off in every game he plays.I would swap him with Barton in a heart beat,but on the creative side we need to give Barkley a good run and in my opinion even to the expense of Arteta who in my opinion has gone stale.
  • bluewookie
    Posts: 137
    BlueJayDee said:

    Hopefully in a year or two, we'll be talking about how Ross Barkley is our best player. The kids got talent



    In a year or two, we will be saying "Who's gonna replace Ross?" We cannot hold onto a player in our current financial situation. We are a selling club pure and simple.
  • lukep08
    Posts: 309
    Probably will loose money on fellaini if he goes, purely because of his contract issues, hes 10-15 good games in two years? your just chatting absolute dribble now milky, hes had 10-15 genuis performances in 3 seasons, and alot of verygood/good games, very rarely has a poor games, got to take into consideration milkky 1st year he played as an attacking mid which he is NOT, other 2 season he has been injured for half of them, if he plays this season fully without getting injured he will be one of our best and most important players, you just choose to criticse him
  • blue4eva77
    Posts: 276
    lisa2blonde said:

    lol - Hibbert

    I know you LOL'd....... might get slated for this but don't give a fck to be honest.

    Hibbert is one of the worst players Everton have had in my lifetime. He is terrible..

    ' He tries and gives his all ' doesn't work with me.

  • milky71
    Posts: 9,113
    lukep08 said:

    Probably will loose money on fellaini if he goes, purely because of his contract issues, hes 10-15 good games in two years? your just chatting absolute dribble now milky, hes had 10-15 genuis performances in 3 seasons, and alot of verygood/good games, very rarely has a poor games, got to take into consideration milkky 1st year he played as an attacking mid which he is NOT, other 2 season he has been injured for half of them, if he plays this season fully without getting injured he will be one of our best and most important players, you just choose to criticse him





    Incredible the boy has been shocking for us.

    Hope he improves
  • blue4eva77
    Posts: 276
    Tim Howard is Everton's best player.......

    He is in the one position where one slight error could cost us 3 points. Howard has an off day, we lose..... end of.

    We very rarely hear of Howard costing us the game from a howler.

    Consistent and is a top pro in every sense of the word.
  • deso1957bc
    Posts: 545
    blue4eva77 said:

    Tim Howard is Everton's best player.......

    He is in the one position where one slight error could cost us 3 points. Howard has an off day, we lose..... end of.

    We very rarely hear of Howard costing us the game from a howler.

    Consistent and is a top pro in every sense of the word.



    About 4/5 times last year I reckon.
    His positional sense has always been poor..hardly our best imo.

  • milky71
    Posts: 9,113
    Typical Yank response

    Stars and stripes flying in the garden perchance

    P>S Remember Blackburn last season
  • blue4eva77
    Posts: 276
    milky71 said:

    Typical Yank response

    Stars and stripes flying in the garden perchance

    P>S Remember Blackburn last season

    Yes Milky........ i did say rarely.

    How many times a season do we all talk about Arteta, Saha, Jags, Beckford etc making mistakes ? The difference is, is that their mistakes can be dealt with by someone else. Howard makes a mistake and we are a goal down or level



  • blue4eva77
    Posts: 276
    deso1957bc said:

    blue4eva77 said:

    Tim Howard is Everton's best player.......

    He is in the one position where one slight error could cost us 3 points. Howard has an off day, we lose..... end of.

    We very rarely hear of Howard costing us the game from a howler.

    Consistent and is a top pro in every sense of the word.



    About 4/5 times last year I reckon.
    His positional sense has always been poor..hardly our best imo.

    4 or 5 times ?? Costing us the game last season ?



  • milky71
    Posts: 9,113
    blue4eva77 said:

    deso1957bc said:

    blue4eva77 said:

    Tim Howard is Everton's best player.......

    He is in the one position where one slight error could cost us 3 points. Howard has an off day, we lose..... end of.

    We very rarely hear of Howard costing us the game from a howler.

    Consistent and is a top pro in every sense of the word.



    About 4/5 times last year I reckon.
    His positional sense has always been poor..hardly our best imo.

    4 or 5 times ?? Costing us the game last season ?





    Ignore Deso he know's F,all about Football.

    I remember 2 mistakes at least
Add a Comment

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Forum

Poll

No poll attached to this discussion.

In this Discussion