The views below are submitted by registered users of evertonfc.com and do not necessarily reflect the views of Everton Football Club. View the Blueroom acceptable usage policy.

MCFADDEN
  • beardblue boy
    Posts: 381
    Apparently were in talks with him about a return to goodison,i always liked him and although its not a major signing id take him back.
    What are your thoughts?
  • artytango
    Posts: 25
    he's out of contract and Brum dont want to pay his wages , he'd probably have to take a pay cut to come back here
  • Daive521
    Posts: 2,329
    For about a year I've wondered what happened to James Mcfadden??????????
  • lukep08
    Posts: 309
    He is awfull, cant believe some of you would actually take james mcfadden fml
  • Warrington Dan
    Posts: 8,858
    Daive521 said:

    For about a year I've wondered what happened to James Mcfadden??????????



    He suffered a long term injury
  • sambo applecart
    Posts: 24,142
    lukep08 said:

    He is awfull, cant believe some of you would actually take james mcfadden fml




    2 players i would rather not have, Crouch and Mcfadden

  • lukep08
    Posts: 309


    sambo applecart said:

    lukep08 said:

    He is awfull, cant believe some of you would actually take james mcfadden fml




    2 players i would rather not have, Crouch and Mcfadden




    exactly crouch is just a lanky mong, but mcfadden is awfull, wernt good enough a few years ago when we had a worse team than we do know so hes certinaly not good enough now
  • sambo applecart
    Posts: 24,142
    lukep08 said:



    sambo applecart said:

    lukep08 said:

    He is awfull, cant believe some of you would actually take james mcfadden fml




    2 players i would rather not have, Crouch and Mcfadden




    exactly crouch is just a lanky mong, but mcfadden is awfull, wernt good enough a few years ago when we had a worse team than we do know so hes certinaly not good enough now


    Absolutely agree mate :-)

  • blueforyou
    Posts: 50
    this is worse than the paddy McCourt one during the week he would be a waste of a wage lucky to get good money
    for him why would we want him back :-h
  • 11blue
    Posts: 4,669
    McFadden had moments of brilliance, but he was very inconsistent. He scored some brilliant goals but I very much doubt he would be a regular starter for us so I would not want him back.
  • Warrington Dan
    Posts: 8,858
    I think he'd be a decent squad player. I doubt we'd have to pay him too much.
  • 11blue
    Posts: 4,669
    Warrington Dan said:

    I think he'd be a decent squad player. I doubt we'd have to pay him too much.



    Yes he would be a good squad player, but I would rather him not come back. I actually liked McFadden though, he just had to be more consistent.
  • fizzbomb
    Posts: 1,245
    If it come down to a choice of nobody at all or Jimmy Mac i would take him for 12 months.

    He's scored some great goals for club an' country, no doubt about 'is ability,his consistency is the problem, he used to suffer from homesickness in 'is early days at GP, but so did Sharpie.

    He's older, more mature, more experienced and here's the deal-sealer, we took Pistone back, if he can be re-signed then so can anyone!!!!
  • zagan
    Posts: 4,703
    Thanks, but no thanks.
    I'd rather leave the squad as it is.
    He would be nothing more than a waste of wages....
  • IdiAminDaDa
    Posts: 7,454
    zagan said:

    Thanks, but no thanks.
    I'd rather leave the squad as it is.
    He would be nothing more than a waste of wages....



    Yer can tell you're Welsh like...
  • MikeEFC1
    Posts: 14
    Good on his day and scored the odd memorable goal, mainly for Scotland and we got godd money for him because of that, would be a squad player at best!
  • zagan
    Posts: 4,703
    IdiAminDaDa said:

    zagan said:

    Thanks, but no thanks.
    I'd rather leave the squad as it is.
    He would be nothing more than a waste of wages....



    Yer can tell you're Welsh like...


    Want to elaborate on that "like"?
  • Daive521
    Posts: 2,329
    Warrington Dan said:

    Daive521 said:

    For about a year I've wondered what happened to James Mcfadden??????????



    He suffered a long term injury




    Oh, Tar for that info. What was his injury?

  • Warrington Dan
    Posts: 8,858
    Daive521 said:

    Warrington Dan said:

    Daive521 said:

    For about a year I've wondered what happened to James Mcfadden??????????



    He suffered a long term injury




    Oh, Tar for that info. What was his injury?



    he suffered anterior cruciate ligament damage to his left knee. During a training session as well
Add a Comment

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Forum

Poll

No poll attached to this discussion.

In this Discussion